Magic Fountain Homemade Ice Cream in Mattituck, NY

Experience the delicious charm of Magic Fountain Homemade Ice Cream in Mattituck, Long Island. Known for its friendly atmosphere and large selection of flavors, this local favorite draws crowds with lines stretching down the street. Celebrate this iconic treat with a magnet, a pinback or a bottle opener—a perfect way to keep a taste of Mattituck’s sweetest tradition close wherever you go.